Environment

Scientists find why the 'big one' may not have shaken California...yet

The ominous southern San Andreas has been quiet. But that won't last forever.
By Mark Kaufman  on 
Downtown Los Angeles with earthquake warning signs
A major earthquake in Southern California, triggered by the San Andreas Fault, is inevitable. Credit: franckreporter / Getty Images

In the middle of the driest California desert, just along the southerly State Route 86, you can find sun-bleached shells littering the ground.

They're telltale signs of a once colossal lake that has come and gone over the last thousands of years, a place called Lake Cahuilla. Today, the much smaller, and shrinking, Salton Sea takes its place. In a new geologic study, scientists have found Lake Cahuilla may have continually played a role in helping stoke major quakes along the southern portion of the infamous San Andreas Fault — which is overdue for a giant quake, a "big one" in heavily-populated Southern California. (Other big ones have certainly hit other parts of the fault, namely the devastating 1906 quake(opens in a new tab) near San Francisco.) The mighty lake, however, hasn't filled to its max depth of over 300 feet since the early 1730s, back when George Washington was just born.

The San Andreas Fault is a fracture between two of Earth's giant slabs of rocky crust, the North American and Pacific plates. Where they meet in California, unimaginable pressure builds as they press into one another. The fault is continually stressed, accumulating some two centimeters of slip deficit annually. The southern portion of the fault historically releases this energy in powerful ruptures around every 180 years, give or take 40 years. But it hasn't budged in some 300 years.

"Eventually this will have to be released by a big earthquake," Yuri Fialko, a professor of geophysics at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography and coauthor of the research, told Mashable.

The research was recently published(opens in a new tab) in the science journal Nature.

Without the giant lake there, putting enormous pressure on the San Andreas and contributing to a more vulnerable fault, the coming big one — a Southern California quake that could cause some 1,800 deaths(opens in a new tab), $200 billion in damage, and untold disruption — might be further delayed. But, critically, the fault might also accumulate even more pressure, resulting in a more potent temblor.

Crucially, a potential delay isn't a reason to stop preparing for a bad earthquake, emphasized John Vidale, an earthquake researcher at the University of Southern California who had no role in the research. But an even bigger, delayed quake, if that comes to pass, isn't the end of the world. It at least allows people to better prepare, ensure more resilient structures, and beyond.

"I’d guess the additional time to enjoy the calm and prepare and better anticipate what is coming is a net gain over just getting it over with sooner," Vidale told Mashable.

The San Andreas Fault separating the Pacific and North American plates.
The San Andreas Fault separating the massive Pacific and North American plates. Credit: USGS
The outline of the former Lake Cahuilla shown in dark blue. The current Salton Sea is at center (filled with light blue), and the San Andreas Fault is designated "SAF."
The outline of the former Lake Cahuilla shown in dark blue. The current Salton Sea is at center (filled with light blue), and the San Andreas Fault is designated "SAF." Credit: USGS

Triggering the San Andreas Fault

The evidence for Lake Cahuilla triggering major temblors is compelling: Over the last thousand years or so, Colorado River water pouring into this low desert basin has filled the lake six times, according to geologic research. And during each fill, a significant quake occurred, the latest of which was in the 1720s.

"This was an amazing correlation that inspired the modeling part of our study," said Fialko.

Of course, a basic tenant of scientific research is that correlation does not mean causation. (See the ingenious Spurious Correlation(opens in a new tab) website for a poignant detour into spurious correlations). But this correlation is strong. "It's very plausible," noted Vidale. What's more, the researchers were able to run advanced computer simulations, on a supercomputer at San Diego State University, allowing them to see how the lake triggered the earthquakes in this desert region.

A graph showing when Lake Cahuilla filled over the last thousand years. The lake levels are shown in light blue, whereas the corresponding earthquake time probabilities are shown by the dotted black lines below each lake fill episode.
A graph showing when Lake Cahuilla filled over the last thousand years. The lake levels are shown in light blue, whereas the corresponding earthquake time probabilities are shown by the dotted black lines below each lake fill episode. Credit: Hill, et al., 2023

Faults, like the San Andreas, are held together by friction and intense pressure. "Anything that will relieve that pressure will nudge it closer to failure," explained Scripps' Fialko. Two primary factors pushed the southern San Andreas to failure, the researchers concluded. Both were caused by the ancient, giant lake:

  1. Immense water pressed down on Earth's surface, just to the side of the actual fault line. This flexed the ground underneath, and ultimately acted to "unclench" the fault. Now, it could slip.

  2. Lake water percolated down into the fault zone. This water, needing somewhere to go, tried to push apart two sides of the fault. "It encouraged the triggering," Fialko said.

A total of six sizable quakes shook Southern California when the lake filled. Over the last century, the much smaller, and less heavy, Salton Sea filled the desert basin, which is largely sustained by agricultural runoff. It's now evaporating. Water scarcity has increased in the hotter, drying West, and farmers have found ways to more efficiently irrigate crops, leading to less runoff flowing into the artificial sea. In our modern world, where the Colorado River now provides water to some 40 million people(opens in a new tab), there's certainly no water to spare for a sprawling natural lake. Expansive Lake Cahuilla will not come again, at least while civilization is here.

So the question looms: Without a giant lake potentially triggering quakes, when's the big one coming?

The high water mark from Lake Cahuilla preserved on a hill in the Southern California desert.
The high water line from Lake Cahuilla preserved on a hill in the Southern California desert. Credit: USGS

Want more science and tech news delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up for Mashable's Light Speed newsletter today.

What is the earthquake risk from the San Andreas Fault?

It's clear the southern portion of the San Andreas is long overdue.

With no lake present, the "clamping pressure" on the fault increases. This should stabilize the infamous rupture, Fialko said.

But, crucially, there will still be other quakes. "It will not stop the next big earthquake from occurring," Fialko emphasized.

"Eventually there's going to be an earthquake whether the lake fills or not," added Vidale.

We just don't know when. "Earthquakes don't work like a clock," Fialko said. Eventually, maybe today, tomorrow, or in decades, the pressure building between the two plates will inevitably cause the fault to fail.

"Earthquakes don't work like a clock."

Although we now know more, and continue to learn more about the enigmatic San Andreas, the crucial takeaway remains the same: "It underscores the need for preparedness," Fialko said. "Do everything you can to stay prepared."

Importantly, there are faults all over Southern California(opens in a new tab). Faults running parallel to the San Andreas. Faults running perpendicular to it. A fault running through Hollywood. Faults right off the coast(opens in a new tab). Ultimately, depending on where the quake hits along the San Andreas, the biggest risk to you might be something else, much closer to home.

A medical building severely damaged by the Northridge quake in 1994.
A medical building severely damaged by the Northridge quake in 1994. Credit: Joe Sohm / Visions of America / Universal Images Group via Getty Images

"Here in L.A., a lot of the risk is the fault right underneath us," said Vidale. "We have a lot of risks, and many of them aren't from the San Andreas."

How to prepare? There are a number of good resources. The USGS has valuable preparation info(opens in a new tab), as does the California Governor's Office of Emergency Services(opens in a new tab). In general, keep an earthquake disaster kit or storage area, have a family plan, and prepare your home for intense shaking.

The southern section of the San Andreas has been quiet. But that won't last forever.

This story, originally published on June 10, has been updated with more information about the San Andreas Fault.

Mark is an award-winning journalist and the science editor at Mashable. After communicating science as a ranger with the National Park Service, he began a reporting career after seeing the extraordinary value in educating the public about the happenings in earth sciences, space, biodiversity, health, and beyond. 

You can reach Mark at [email protected](opens in a new tab).


Recommended For You
XREAL (formerly Nreal) Air AR glasses are so cool, but need some serious work

Exploding volcano does something scientists have never seen before

Scientists find something exciting brewing in Enceladus' seas


This jacket uses fog to supply you with healthy water

More in Science
How to cancel your Amazon Prime membership


DoorDash expands grocery access through SNAP and EBT payment options


Paying for Prime Day purchases with Affirm: With great power comes great responsibility

Trending on Mashable
Wordle today: Here's the answer and hints for July 1

Spectacular Webb telescope image reveals things scientists can't explain

Twitter now blocks visitors from viewing tweets, and profiles unless they're logged in

Want to try swinging? Here's a beginner's guide.

Elon Musk claims Twitter login requirement just 'temporary'
The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
This newsletter may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. Subscribing to a newsletter indicates your consent to our Terms of Use(opens in a new tab) and Privacy Policy(opens in a new tab). You may unsubscribe from the newsletters at any time.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!